« Real musicals | Main | Catching up with catching up »

March 16, 2008

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Mark Jeffries

What's your view of the slamming of B.J. on Chris Jones' blog? Justified or unjustified? (I haven't seen a Northlight show since they moved up to Skokie, but I've always liked B.J. as an actor and especially liked him as a person.) I can't really figure out the bitterness.

Ed

I'll echo my own wistful casting wishes for Gray Gardens- and maybe expand on them a little bit.

For Big Edie in act II- Deanna Dunagan (quite a good singer in addition to her other talents; she did well in "Bounce")

For Little Edie in act II (the Ebersole track)- I agree it's a tough one. But my vote if it goes to a Chicagoan? Rebecca Finnegan. I think she's got the vocal chops, and god knows she can act it.

Little Edie in act I...Jess Godwin maybe? For the young guy maybe Brandon Dahlquist.

I think the really difficult part in that show to case it George Gould Strong- not really thinking of anyone local who can capture that character *and* accompany themselves that well...unless, does Guy Adkins play piano?

Ed

Just thought of someone. Let Jon Steinhagen do the part!

Kris Vire

Mark: I was sort of mystified by the vitriol aimed at Northlight on Chris's blog as well. I can't say I was around to follow Northlight before BJ's tenure, but still.

Ed: Good instincts, dude. Finnegan had occurred to me as a possibility as well. Of course there are the union issues to consider—if I'm keeping track correctly, only three of your five recommendations are Equity, and I don't know what Northlight's contract calls for.

Mark Jeffries

B.J.'s predecessor was Russell Vanden Brouke, a genial sort who was much more of the intellectual type than B.J., and his play choices pretty much reflected that (even though he usually had one more populist piece in a season). It seemed to me that he left shortly after they moved into the North Shore Center and that he got forced out because it was felt his shows weren't commercial enough. Although Vanden Brouke had the unenviable task of following Michael Maggio after he was asked to sit at the right hand of Bob Falls at the Goodman, he managed to stay around and keep the company going through some tough times before Skokie (they lost their original space in Evanston and had the lousy former movie theater in Evanston for a few years).

Where the vitriol seems to be coming is from the show tune contingent who doesn't like how B.J. (or so-called "straight play directors"--see Chris Jones' thread on "Carousel") directs musicals. Although if you read Chris' blog, it almost seems like these people don't like *any* musical directors unless they're imports from New York. They also think that sauerkraut should be put on hot dogs and pizza crust should taste like cardboard. :)

And Ed is dead on. Rebecca hasn't had a knockout role since turning Equity (it often does that, kids) and "Gray Gardens" sure as hell beats doing another Light Opera Works fall revue.

Jon Steinhagen

I'm flattered by Ed's suggestion that I could play George in "Grey Gardens," and believe me, I'd leap at the opportunity; however, as Kris points out, I'm a non-Equity actor who also happens to be a union musician. Although I'd kill to work with Rebecca and Brandon again, I have no immediate prospects of being an Equity actor and am not on Northlight's radar. The best I can do is be ready to buy tickets to Northlight's production of what, in my opinion, is one of the three most important developments in musical theatre since 2005. Which doesn't mean I won't keep my fingers crossed!

I hope "Grey Gardens" sparks a trend in future musicals: a marvellously compelling, offbeat story steeped in CHARACTER rather than SPECTACLE, penned by an important playwright with an intelligent, tuneful and dramatic score. And, like Kris, I too cannot wait to see what comes of the Whitty/Moore-helmed TALES OF THE CITY...maybe they should hire the songwriters of GREY GARDENS to write the score? Just a thought. Regardless, this is all good news for MusicalTheatreLand, which always needs an injection of good news.

Ed

Hey Jon- agreed that Grey Gardens was an important new piece...in your opinion what are the other two important developments since 2005 in musical theatre? My vote if I absolutely had to name just two would be "The Light in the Piazza" and "Spring Awakening." But I'd love to hear your take on it.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Who? What?

  • Kris Vire
    I write about theater for Time Out Chicago. I write more about it here.

    Any opinion expressed here is solely that of the author or commenter. No opinion expressed here can be assumed to represent the opinion of Time Out Chicago magazine.

@krisvire on Twitter

    follow me on Twitter

    Recently Seen

    • 06/24: Cherrywood (Mary-Arrchie Theatre Company)
    • 06/20: Sweet and Hot: The Songs of Harold Arlen (Theo Ubique)
    • 06/16: Shakespeare's King Phycus (Strange Tree Group)
    • 06/12: Sketchbook (Collaboraction)
    • 06/11: Dead Letter Office (Dog & Pony Theatre Company)
    • 06/09: Itsoseng (Chicago Shakespeare Theater)
    • 06/05: Low Down Dirty Blues (Northlight)
    • 06/04: Inherit the Whole (Mortar Theatre)
    • 05/27: Hunting and Gathering (Theatre Seven of Chicago)
    • 05/25: Fuerza Bruta (Broadway in Chicago)
    • 05/24: War with the Newts (Next Theatre)
    • 05/20: Baal (TUTA)
    • 05/19: The 39 Steps (nat'l tour)
    • 05/13: A Streetcar Named Desire (Writers' Theatre)
    • 05/12: From a Fading Light (Plasticene)
    • 05/10: Neverwhere (Lifeline Theatre)
    • 05/09: The Good Negro (Goodman)
    • 05/07: Sweet Tea (About Face)
    • 05/05: The Last Cargo Cult (Mike Daisey @ Victory Gardens)
    • 05/03: The Love of the Nightingale (Red Tape Theatre)
    Blog powered by Typepad

    Visitors